Sep 4 2010

Virtualization At The Data Tier, Some Thoughts

Posted by Mike Brunt at 1:28 PM
38 comments
- Categories: DataBase | CloudComputing | Default

Recently, Clement Huge, our DBA, attended a series of high-level meetings relating to virtualization with VMWare or HyperV for the data tier. The meetings considered physical HA installations (SQL server cluster, oracle RAC   on machine with geographical redundancy, etc...) and VMWare or HyperV HA virtualization. The meetings produced some concrete conclusions, which he summarizes as follows.  

  • Virtualization can be a very good HA solution*: VMware for example will expose the database "engine" as a stand-alone entity for the DBA and the DBA would not be responsible for the HA solution. The system engineer, in charge of the virtualization will bear the responsibility for ensuring continuity.  Virtualization has become mature in developing such solutions. In essence VMWare would manage the two virtual nodes and as this is the database engine, shared disk resources do not present a problem anymore as you can add more disk in a much easier way by virtualization.  Downtime would be probably a bit longer perhaps 2 minutes, instead of 1 minute on a physical installation but this is still reasonable timeframe from a DBA perspective. 
  • Virtualization is not the same as a physical device*: Database virtualization requires a thorough knowledge and expertise in the field. Virtualization applied poorly at the data tier will almost certainly produce very poor performance at the database engine level. We have seen degradations in performance from equivalent physical to virtual servers as high as 30%.  Using a virtual machine is not the same as using a physical device and this is a very important point to bear in mind.     
  • No virtualization at the storage level*: The operating system will handle logically all things such as partition alignment and cluster size *64k* however the physical hard drives simply present a pool of storage to the virtual machine which can then allocated from that pool creating virtual hard drives.  In our experience one of the most debilitating problems for databases to deal with is hard drive I/O, for that reason we always play close attention to the hard-drives/controllers etc.  We do not recommend any virtualization at the database storage level, drives should be physical and individually identifiable.  Also remember that with a SAN or any attached device there are still elements of a single point of failure.  Lastly, if there needs to be a connection from the database engine to an attached storage device it should be gigabit Ethernet at a minimum and preferably fiber channel
  • Be aware of OEM Vendor support*: Microsoft does not support SQL Server running on a non-Microsoft virtual solution and this is an important consideration if support is required from Microsoft.

 

 

Comments

handbags

handbags wrote on 11/19/10 7:07 PM

Your blog article is very intersting and fanstic,at the same time the blog theme is unique and perfect,great job.To your success..
MARK

MARK wrote on 12/14/10 1:27 PM

what is the. best treatment for panic attacks.? my sister has the Panic attack.I want to cure her.I always search some forums about
this.I founds this website about this.anyone have some experience with them?
qiudong

qiudong wrote on 03/16/11 10:30 PM

before http://feiyue.eu.com the dinner, the host should http://feiyue.eu.com/feiyue-low-cut-cancas write the full name of each http://feiyue.eu.com/feiyue-hight-cut-leather guest in fancy print on little cards and place them at
Custom flag

Custom flag wrote on 07/12/11 3:05 AM

ohh man this is awesome post.i think they should usebanner to get more flow in look.
you know this is great working by the writer.The writer has done a great job in speniding his time in
research about this article. can i subscribe all his posts ?
I am really happy to read this. i was searching this from last two months and atlast i got it. hurrah..!!
cartier bracelet love

cartier bracelet love wrote on 07/13/11 5:03 AM

It's so great that you guys are sticking with it! I've been following the team for some time and am so happy that
now the fire is burning brighter than ever! Way to stay positive and stick with something you love!
Herve Leger Dresses Sale

Herve Leger Dresses Sale wrote on 08/22/11 10:35 AM

We can offer you not only the lowest price but also best quality Herve Leger Dresses Sale UK ,Free Shipping & Customs!
True Religion

True Religion wrote on 08/23/11 4:54 AM

Hey, you say nice topic! I very like your article, hope you will continue to update your article and topic, more exciting, go here!
web design London

web design London wrote on 08/23/11 10:20 PM

Really nice summery of the conclusion.I like it so much.
Coach Bags

Coach Bags wrote on 08/30/11 5:34 AM

"Thank you very much for you perfect and useful post .it's really valuable.
bags

bags wrote on 09/16/11 8:23 PM

i think very nice
LVpacks

LVpacks wrote on 09/16/11 8:25 PM

very good..

i like this
Kayako

Kayako wrote on 09/19/11 6:02 AM

I just study how to use virtual solutions, so thanks for the tips.
Burberry bags on sale

Burberry bags on sale wrote on 09/30/11 2:21 AM

i wish to understand a lot more about this because it in fact catches my attention. Keep on posting useful facts about this dude! Thank you so considerably for sharing.
sheepskin ugg boots

sheepskin ugg boots wrote on 10/13/11 1:41 AM

Your blog article is very intersting and fanstic,at the same time the blog theme is unique and perfect,great job.To your success..i like it very much.
gucci hat

gucci hat wrote on 10/13/11 1:42 AM

very good...i like it so much.
online jewellery

online jewellery wrote on 10/20/11 5:43 AM

I got lucky and found your site from a random Google search. Fortunately for me, this topic just happens to be something that I’ve been trying to find more info on for research purpose. Keep us the great and thanks a lot.
ASH sandals

ASH sandals wrote on 10/26/11 12:00 AM

Ashshop.org is an ASH online store,Ash Shoes have constantly been acknowledged by the retail shoes business as the shoes and boots for all seasons. Being so, Ash shoes and boots currently have one of the most comprehensive collections of styles. Catering to males and women for whichever requirements they actually have. The Ash shoes assortment has it all. From active shoes to fashion footwear, the Ash logo has marked
new zealand flowers delivery

new zealand flowers delivery wrote on 10/27/11 2:59 AM

I really like this kind of stuff. Thanks for sharing it.
cheap ugg boots

cheap ugg boots wrote on 10/30/11 8:33 PM

ugg Australia rushed out of the real world, the first stop is the United States, its appearance was originally prepared for surfers, there are several benefits, warm cold, dampness, keeping feet dry and comfortable.
replica cheap handbags

replica cheap handbags wrote on 10/30/11 8:34 PM

briefcase and bag unique signature tag, as the Coach brand's trademark, has been widely recognized at home and abroad, it is eager. This is Coach function, technology, fashion and style definitions. Coach seamless fashion innovation that will be sharp and the integration of modern American attitudes, in order to unparalleled skill. <a href="http://replica-cheaphandbags.com/coach-handbags-c-69.html">cheap coach handbags</a>
replica designer handbags

replica designer handbags wrote on 10/30/11 8:35 PM

Gucci's PR heard earlier that they open in Florence to mark the 90th anniversary of the museum, it is curious that Gucci on the 90th anniversary of the major activities is how to celebrate, they will get what the museum today, the mystery of this curious it opened, the museum was officially opened today, and I found some pictures on display in the museum. http://www.shopwholesalehandbags.com/replica-designer-handbags-gucci-handbags-c-1_9.html Gucci handbags and Jewellery
uggs sheepskin

uggs sheepskin wrote on 11/01/11 8:23 PM

Press speculation, to do this trick Dexter is very successful, the number of the world's fashion magazines, ugg snow boots can see the figure, and also are associated with star appear, thus further enhance the the popularity of ugg snow boots, ugg snow boots sales began leaps and bounds.
woman ugg boos classic http://www.sheepskin-ugg.co.uk/woman-ugg-boots-classic-boots-classic-tall-5815-c-1_35.html boots classic tall
Replicas Coach

Replicas Coach wrote on 11/16/11 12:02 AM

Ashshop.org is an ASH online store,Ash Shoes have constantly been acknowledged by the retail shoes business as the shoes and boots for all seasons. Being so, Ash shoes and boots currently have one of the most comprehensive collections of styles.
Replicas Handbags

Replicas Handbags wrote on 11/16/11 12:03 AM

I got lucky and found your site from a random Google search. Fortunately for me, this topic just happens to be something that I’ve been trying to find more info on for research purpose.
Replicas Handbags

Replicas Handbags wrote on 11/16/11 11:32 PM

I got lucky and found your site from a random Google search. Fortunately for me, this topic just happens to be something that I’ve been trying to find more info on for research purpose.
superdry sale

superdry sale wrote on 11/18/11 6:08 PM

Every superdry sale fans convinced superdry will be next huge designer. The colors of superdry uk are just amazing because they are universally flattering! It is a great alternative for people who are tired of buying out the entire superdry outlet line and are finished shopping at Our Superdry uk sale store.
qjkider

qjkider wrote on 11/24/11 4:13 PM

Daily meticulously shaping a hair, will make people look extra spirit [url=http://www.bestlisseurghdfr.info/][b]ghd lisseur[/b][/url] Today we introduce some friends of female beauty does not hurt the hair shaping straight hair, [url=http://www.bestlisseurghdfr.info/][b]styler ghd [/b][/url]the product uses a high temperature ceramic plates, [url=http://www.bestlisseurghdfr.info/][b]lisser ghd[/b][/url] hair can minimize the damage will be. Straight hair looks elegant design [url=http://www.bestlisseurghdfr.info/][b]ghd hair straighteners[/b][/url] Body with a high temperature ceramic plates smooth and delicate texture to prevent their hair, [url=http://www.bestlisseurghdfr.info/][b]ghd france[/b][/url] to protect the scalp healthy.
Michael kors handbags

Michael kors handbags wrote on 11/30/11 11:27 PM

Comfortabl y, the post is really the sweetest topic on this related issue. I harmonize with your conclusions and will thirstily look forward to your approaching updates. Saying thanks will not just be enough, for the tremendous lucidity in your writing. I will instantly grab your rss feed to stay privy of any updates.
Replicas Handbags

Replicas Handbags wrote on 12/11/11 10:45 PM

Thank you for your concern, it is noted, all of you at ease. Without fear of worry. Really. Very.
Replicas Handbags

Replicas Handbags wrote on 12/11/11 10:47 PM

I feel very good life now, do not ask too much, too good to very good now, is not it? Contented. Cheap Replica Handbags
Replicas Handbags

Replicas Handbags wrote on 12/13/11 10:37 PM

Coach quickly became renown not only for their style but also quality. With an expanding company and product line, we continue to expect and be given innovative lines and multiple collections every season.
Replicas COACH Handbags

Replicas COACH Handbags wrote on 12/15/11 10:52 PM

Thank you for your concern, it is noted, all of you at ease. Without fear of worry. Really. Very.
Cheap Replicas Handbags

Cheap Replicas Handbags wrote on 12/15/11 10:52 PM

I feel very good life now, do not ask too much, too good to very good now, is not it? Contented.
real estate toronto

real estate toronto wrote on 12/25/11 7:52 PM

wow. I can only relate a little because of these has been discussed in our school.
Replicas Cheap COACH Handbags

Replicas Cheap COACH Handbags wrote on 12/28/11 12:00 AM

i wish to understand a lot more about this because it in fact catches my attention. Keep on posting useful facts about this dude! Thank you so considerably for sharing.
indianapolis super bowl

indianapolis super bowl wrote on 02/03/12 2:32 AM

wow. i tried to virtualize the SQL but Still i was not able to understand the whole thing, if you;ve got any chance, please do help me. thanks.
Cheap Replicas Handbags

Cheap Replicas Handbags wrote on 02/04/12 6:36 PM

Toile Trianon Canvas first ask the city, the price fifty thousand jump, change Antigua line appearance the month, the same three packages, the entry value nearly two million, the prices over interest!
Replicas Cheap COACH Handbags

Replicas Cheap COACH Handbags wrote on 02/04/12 6:38 PM

Thank you for your concern, it is noted, all of you at ease. Without fear of worry. Really. Very.

Write your comment



(it will not be displayed)



Leave this field empty: